American Fidelity logo

American Fidelity

Insurance · Nationwide

americanfidelity.com

How to name beneficiaries and fund a trust at American Fidelity

Beneficiaries are managed by phone or by mail. Trust paperwork is taken by phone or by mail

Estate planning with American Fidelity policies centers on beneficiary designations—the single most important step for ensuring life insurance proceeds and annuity benefits reach the intended recipients without probate involvement. Unlike bank or brokerage accounts, insurance products are not retitled into trusts; instead, trusts are named as beneficiaries when estate tax planning or controlled distributions are needed.

Across 14 product types, American Fidelity policies vary in how they transfer at death. The sections below walk through beneficiary designations, trust funding options, and which products support each method.

Beneficiary form at American Fidelity

Change of Beneficiary Form (PS-138-1124), for life and supplemental policies, Annuity Change of Beneficiary Form (ANN-187-0523) (for annuitys) and Request for Change of Beneficiary (PS-175-0823), for Life Division policies (for life insurance policys).

Open the form →
American Fidelity Traditional and Roth IRA
1
Call American Fidelity at 800-662-1113, Monday through Friday, 7:00 a.m. to 7:00 p.m. Central
2
Tell the representative:
  • Your policy number and identifying information
  • Whether the policy is life/supplemental (PS-138), an annuity contract (ANN-187), or serviced by the Life Division (PS-175)
3
The representative mails the correct form or walks you through completing it; the signed paper form still has to be returned by email, mail or fax

Required Documents

  • Policy owner, insured and customer number. The owner's SSN or Tax ID is also given if the owner is a trust or organization
  • Each beneficiary's full legal name
  • Each beneficiary's address
  • Each beneficiary's Social Security number or Tax ID
  • Each beneficiary's date of birth
  • Each beneficiary's relationship to the insured
  • Trust name, trust date and trustee (when naming a trust). Written in American Fidelity's printed wording: "The John J. Doe Trust dated xx/xx/xxxx, Jane Doe as Trustee"
  • Trust Tax Identification Number (when naming a trust). Entered in the SSN/Tax ID field
  • Trust agreement declaration page (on PS-138 or ANN-187, when a trust owns the policy or is named). Shows the trust name, the trust date and every trustee
  • Complete trust agreement (on PS-175, when a trust owns the policy)
  • Copy of the owner's active government-issued ID (on PS-138, in place of a witness). A copy of the spouse's ID is accepted in place of a spouse witness
  • Copy of the owner's valid photo ID (on ANN-187, for an annuity contract). The spouse's photo ID is also required for owners in AK, AZ, CA, ID, LA, NV, NM, TX, WA, WI or PR
  • Entire divorce decree, including the full property settlement (where the community property rule applies and the owner divorced)
  • Death certificate of a deceased spouse (where the community property rule applies and a spouse has died)

What American Fidelity says about beneficiaries and trusts

Each section is American Fidelity's own statement, with the document it comes from numbered under Sources.

Which accounts take a beneficiary3

Life insurance policy

A beneficiary change on term, whole or universal life is made on the Change of Beneficiary Form (PS-138), which asks for each life policy number.1

Policies serviced by the separate Life Division take their beneficiary change on the Request for Change of Beneficiary (PS-175) instead.2

Health, long-term care or disability policy

Accident, cancer, disability, critical illness and hospital indemnity policies take a beneficiary designation; each is a policy type listed on PS-138.1

Annuity

An annuity contract's beneficiary is changed on the Annuity Change of Beneficiary Form (ANN-187).3

Who can be named1

A trust, life insurance policys

A trust can be named beneficiary of a life policy on the Change of Beneficiary Form (PS-138).1

A trust, annuitys

An annuity contract can name a trust as beneficiary on ANN-187.3

A trust, IRAs

An IRA can name a trust as beneficiary on ANN-187.3

How many beneficiaries, and how shares are split

All accounts

Benefits are divided by percentage, never by dollar amount. Primary shares must total 100%, and contingent shares must total 100%.1

What a designation takes to be effective

All accounts

PS-138 requires a witness signature; the witness must be over 18 and not a beneficiary on the form. A copy of the owner's active government-issued ID is accepted in place of a witness.1

If the policy is jointly owned, all owners must sign. A joint life policy needs a separate form for each insured, and both insureds must sign.1

If a trust owns the policy, all trustees must sign.1, 2

If the policy was issued in, or the owner lives or has lived in, Alaska, Arizona, California, Idaho, Louisiana, Nevada, New Mexico, Puerto Rico, Washington or Wisconsin, the spouse at issue and every spouse during the policy term must sign.1, 2

Only the policy owner, or the person with control of a juvenile policy, can change beneficiaries.4

Life insurance policy

The Life Division's form (PS-175) requires a witness on each signature and bars an owner from witnessing.2

Annuity

ANN-187 requires a copy of the owner's valid photo ID, plus the spouse's photo ID for owners in Alaska, Arizona, California, Idaho, Louisiana, Nevada, New Mexico, Texas, Washington, Wisconsin or Puerto Rico.3

Beneficiary forms American Fidelity issues3

Change of Beneficiary Form (PS-138-1124), for life and supplemental policies

Completed by the policy owner. Available to download.1

Return to

Email: beneficiarychanges@americanfidelity.com

Fax: 1-800-620-8915

Mailing address: American Fidelity, P.O. Box 25523, Oklahoma City, OK 73125

Annuity Change of Beneficiary Form (ANN-187-0523)

For annuitys. Completed by the contract owner. Available to download.3

Return to

Email: annuity-services@americanfidelity.com

Fax: 1-405-523-5978

Mailing address: Annuity Services Department, P.O. Box 25520, Oklahoma City, OK 73125-0520

Request for Change of Beneficiary (PS-175-0823), for Life Division policies

For life insurance policys. Available to download.2

Return to

Email: life-DCS-customerservice@americanfidelity.com

Fax: 1-405-523-3841

Mailing address: P.O. Box 268923, Oklahoma City, OK 73126-8923

What American Fidelity's agreement says about beneficiaries5

Changing or revoking a designation

A new designation supersedes all previous ones, so every beneficiary who should still receive proceeds must be listed again.1

A designation and a will

Beneficiary designations control over instructions in a will.4

When a designation takes effect

A change is not effective until American Fidelity approves it, and a confirmation copy is then sent.1, 3

A minor as beneficiary

American Fidelity advises against naming a minor child directly.4

Changing the owner of a policy or account

On the Change of Ownership Form (PS-140), a minor cannot be listed as a new policy owner until reaching the age of majority for their state.5

Which accounts a trust can hold4

Life insurance policy

An Irrevocable Life Insurance Trust can own a life policy through the Change of Ownership Form (PS-140).5

Annuity

An annuity contract cannot be retitled to a trust while the annuitant is living.4

IRA

An IRA cannot be retitled to a trust while the annuitant is living.4

Health, long-term care or disability policy

The supplemental products (disability, cancer, critical illness, accident only, Hospital GAP PLAN, hospital indemnity and paid leave) pay their benefits to the insured during life and cannot be trust-owned.4

Trust account forms American Fidelity issues1

Change of Ownership Form (PS-140)

For life insurance policys. Available to download.5

Return to

Fax: 1-800-620-8915

Mailing address: Client Policy Services, P.O. Box 25523, Oklahoma City, OK 73125-0160

What American Fidelity says about trust accounts2

A trust as owner of a policy

American Fidelity does not set up Irrevocable Life Insurance Trusts.4

When a designation takes effect

A change of ownership is effective only after American Fidelity approves it; a copy of the approved Request for Change of Ownership is returned to the owner.5

Accounts handled elsewhere1

American Fidelity Life Division

Life policies serviced by the separate Life Division, which use the Request for Change of Beneficiary (PS-175)2

Phone: 1-800-735-9701

Email: life-DCS-customerservice@americanfidelity.com

Fax: 1-405-523-3841

Mailing address: P.O. Box 268923, Oklahoma City, OK 73126-8923

Not in American Fidelity's published guidance1

  • An online way to name a beneficiary

Sources5

SimplyTrustSimplyTrust Editorial·

Sources

Data sourced from American Fidelity primary sources (18 pages reviewed). How we research.

Download these American Fidelity instructions

Download instructions for the whole estate

A printable PDF with the steps, required documents, and contact details — verified against American Fidelity primary sources. Bring it to the branch or keep it beside the phone.

American Fidelity estate support

Customer Service

Life Division (PS-175 policies)

Policy Continuation after leaving an employer

Health & Welfare Consulting Services

Fax

1-800-620-8915

Hours

Monday-Friday 7:00 AM-7:00 PM CT

Mailing address

American Fidelity Assurance Company, 9000 Cameron Parkway, Oklahoma City, OK 73114

Estate requests go through general customer service.

Verified Sep 2026

Estate planning articles

Learn how to protect your American Fidelity accounts and other assets with trusts, beneficiary designations, and estate planning documents.

Forms for Planning Your Estate

Free forms for planning your estate: a will, living trust, pour-over will, both powers of attorney, living will, and TOD deed.

Free

Pour-Over Will

Catch anything outside your trust. Pairs with your revocable trust.

Get Started
$12/month

Revocable Living Trust

Create a revocable living trust to avoid probate, protect privacy, and control asset distribution.

Get Started
Free

Last Will and Testament

Name your heirs, guardians, and final wishes. Free for every state.

Get Started
Free

Healthcare Power of Attorney

Name someone to make medical decisions if you can't.

Get Started
Free

Financial Power of Attorney

Name someone to manage your finances if you can't.

Get Started
Free

Transfer on Death Deed

Transfer real property to a beneficiary upon your death without probate. Available in 34 states and the District of Columbia.

Get Started
Free

Vehicle Transfer on Death

Name a beneficiary to inherit your vehicle at death without probate. Available in 26 states and the District of Columbia.

Get Started
Free

Living Will

State in advance which life-sustaining treatments you want or refuse, in the document your state recognizes, with signing instructions from the statute.

Get Started

All forms

Tools for Planning Your Estate

Free tools for planning your estate: what a will or trust costs, whether you need a trust or TOD deed, and how documents are signed.

How Much Does a Revocable Living Trust Cost?

Compare revocable living trust costs across providers including online services and attorneys.

Compare Costs

How Does SimplyTrust Compare to LegalZoom, Trust & Will, and Other Services?

Compare what it costs to make a trust official across SimplyTrust, LegalZoom, Trust & Will, Rocket Lawyer, and Quicken WillMaker.

Compare Services

Do I Need a Revocable Trust?

Find out if a revocable trust makes sense based on your state, estate value, and family situation.

Check Now

Trust or Will: Which Costs Less?

Compare the cost of probate vs a trust for your state and estate value.

Compare Options

What Does Estate Planning Actually Cost?

Compare costs across estate planning providers including online services and attorneys.

Compare Costs

How Much Life Insurance Do I Need?

Calculate your life insurance needs based on income, debts, and family situation.

Use Calculator

Are My Beneficiary Designations Protected?

Check how divorce, creditors, and state laws affect your beneficiary designations.

Check Now

How Do I Sign Estate Documents?

Find witness, notary, and remote signing requirements for all 50 states.

Check Requirements

All tools